Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Anything related to Navigation and Questions
User avatar
Fox
Overseas Marshal
Overseas Marshal
Posts: 1162
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 9:00 am
Location: Abu Dhabi

Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by Fox »

I just want to share an experience. My Montana 650 is mounted with the original
Garmin windshield suction mount.
I realized that when I navigated to a certain co-ordinate using the compass page,
the compass swirls around without clear direction indication, as soon as I am
driving very slow or am stopped. This was very annoying.
After long brainstorming and various tests, I had the mount opened and the
internal loudspeaker removed. Thanks to AMIT ! VOILA ! The problem is solved !
So it was the magnetic field from the loudspeaker disturbing the Garmin magnetic
compass.
Now I do not have a voice any more when navigating on the road, but I have
clear direction in the desert. I keep the loudspeaker, it can be re-installed any
time.

User avatar
zeer
Posts: 1493
Joined: Thu Feb 18, 2010 8:22 pm
Location: Abu Dhabi

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by zeer »

Thanks for sharing :smile:
Eyad Harb - 0501234066
One for All & All for One
"BANNA WAS A GOOD MAN..MISSED BUT NEVER FORGOTTEN"
DesNav2011 / DesNav2012 / DesNav2013 / JeeP Jamboree 2013 / Desert Clean / EDC trainer / Sanid Leader
2010-2012 Trips (counter)/(lead): Newbie(27)(02) Intermediate(60)(10) Advance(19)(02) Expert(02)(01) TOTAL (108)/(15)
----2013--- Trips (counter)/(lead): Newbie(12)(04) Intermediate(17)(05) Advance(21)(03) Expert(04)(00) TOTAL (55)/(12)

User avatar
scotchyl
Marshal
Marshal
Posts: 3946
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 10:28 pm
Location: Abu Dhabi

Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by scotchyl »

That was starting to puzzle me. Great work. Thank you.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free
Focus on the future, that's where your life is going. Focus on the past and you will go nowhere.

User avatar
akhateeb
Posts: 684
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2012 9:00 am
Location: Dubai
Location: Discovery Gardens - Dubai

Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by akhateeb »

Great point.. Thanks for sharing.. It is frustrating indeed!

You might want to try the marine type mount then, it doesn't have a loud speaker, but instead connections to connect to any speaker or Aux input.
Alternatively, you can simply fabricate your existing one.. Just extend the two speaker wires to an external speaker that is away.. Or the stereo aux input if any..
Every man dies ... Not every man REALLY lives!
Ayman 0508144630
_________________________
[*] 2014: Nissan Xterra 2014.. Stock except the front bumper..
[*] 2013-2014: Wrangler TJ, 3" Lift, Borla Catback, Roll Cage, Warn Bumpers & Winch, 2 ARB Lockers.. we're almost there!!
[*] 2012-2014: Infinity QX4, OME coils & Shocks around 20 mm additional height, 265x70x16 Cooper AT3 tires, custom pathy bumper, K&N filter ... !
[*] Audi A6 for the lovely wife...
Total Trips since Sep 2012 : 54 Trips
Last updated: 25-NOV-2013

User avatar
waqmaster
Marshal
Marshal
Posts: 1856
Joined: Fri Oct 09, 2009 4:36 pm
Location: Dubai

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by waqmaster »

the montans compass does not require a gps connection :)

wolle
Advanced
Advanced
Posts: 314
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2010 10:53 pm
Location: Abu Dhabi

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by wolle »

Fox wrote:I just want to share an experience. My Montana 650 is mounted with the original
Garmin windshield suction mount.
I realized that when I navigated to a certain co-ordinate using the compass page,
the compass swirls around without clear direction indication, as soon as I am
driving very slow or am stopped. This was very annoying.
After long brainstorming and various tests, I had the mount opened and the
internal loudspeaker removed. Thanks to AMIT ! VOILA ! The problem is solved !
So it was the magnetic field from the loudspeaker disturbing the Garmin magnetic
compass.
Now I do not have a voice any more when navigating on the road, but I have
clear direction in the desert. I keep the loudspeaker, it can be re-installed any
time.

Hallo Fox,

the crusial info in your post is " navigated to a certain co-ordinate using the compass page " so you are only using the layout of a compass but still navigating through GPS, so there is no influence of a magnetic field on that function. The nerves appearance stops when you are driving a few meters.

Regards


Wolfgang

User avatar
akhateeb
Posts: 684
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2012 9:00 am
Location: Dubai
Location: Discovery Gardens - Dubai

Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by akhateeb »

Hi Wolle,

Still, the direction is calculated using the magnetic compass at stop.. & if you are moving it will use the movement direction from the GPS reception..

It is annoying that when you stop the compass direction is very wrong & you have to move to get it right..

To counter this, I used to keep the track log visible so I know where my path was & understand where to go in comparison..

I faced that a lot last DesNav & surely you can live with it once you get used to that.. But having an accurate direction from magnetic compass is very useful...
Every man dies ... Not every man REALLY lives!
Ayman 0508144630
_________________________
[*] 2014: Nissan Xterra 2014.. Stock except the front bumper..
[*] 2013-2014: Wrangler TJ, 3" Lift, Borla Catback, Roll Cage, Warn Bumpers & Winch, 2 ARB Lockers.. we're almost there!!
[*] 2012-2014: Infinity QX4, OME coils & Shocks around 20 mm additional height, 265x70x16 Cooper AT3 tires, custom pathy bumper, K&N filter ... !
[*] Audi A6 for the lovely wife...
Total Trips since Sep 2012 : 54 Trips
Last updated: 25-NOV-2013

User avatar
9ball
Advanced
Advanced
Posts: 2372
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2008 9:00 am
Location: Abu Dhabi
Location: Abu Dhabi

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by 9ball »

Hmmm, very interesting indeed! Never really noticed, pretty much stopped paying attention to my GPS when am in Sweihan or Al Khatim 8-) , but will check next time am out in the dunes.
Desnav team: Whassup? with Waqmaster and Triplod.
2008 Jeep Wrangler Sahara Unlimited 4 doors for the dunes
Spidertrax lift kit, Old Man Emu suspension, Mopar Cold Air Intake, extra radiator for transmission, Mickey Thompson Classic II wheels, KC lights, more stuff to come.
2012 Mustang convertible for the highway and speeding tickets
Predator cues for the pool table (Samsara for play, BK2 for break, Air for jump, Predator case)
Black Belt in Karate
PADI Rescue Diver and Nitrox certified
Super hot wife, 3 cats: one weird looking Sphynx, one crazy fat Arabian Mau and one we are not sure about but not a whole lot smarter
nineballwizard on PS4 Call of Duty games

/l ,[_____],
l----L-OlllllllO-
()_) ()_)-o-)_)


Proud to be Marshal with best club in UAE

User avatar
MalteJK
Posts: 2028
Joined: Sun May 29, 2011 11:19 pm
Location: Dubai
Contact:

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by MalteJK »

Maybe instead of totally removing the speaker ... lengthen the cables for them and put an external speaker, same speaker or aux cable on the other end - but just with enough distance ?
http://www.oryx4x4.com

“Some people never go crazy, What truly horrible lives they must live”
c.b.

#green Jk Sahara ( totally stock ) ( 2013 -
#green Jk Sport ( totally struck ) ( 2013 - 2013 )
#white nissan badroll(stuck) ( 2012-2013 )
#silver jk Sahara unlimited ( stock ) ( 2010- )

phone : 0567786537

lead: Newbie(2) Intermediate(11), Advanced(5)

User avatar
Fox
Overseas Marshal
Overseas Marshal
Posts: 1162
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 9:00 am
Location: Abu Dhabi

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by Fox »

akhateeb wrote:Great point.. Thanks for sharing.. It is frustrating indeed!

You might want to try the marine type mount then, it doesn't have a loud speaker, but instead connections to connect to any speaker or Aux input.
Alternatively, you can simply fabricate your existing one.. Just extend the two speaker wires to an external speaker that is away.. Or the stereo aux input if any..
Right. I had a look at the marine mount, it would solve this problem. The only thing that stopped me is that
the marine mount has to be fixed on the dashboard by screws. Okay, there is a solution to that also, mounting
tape as I am successfully using for the Garmin 276C mount.
Another solution if I decide I want the loudspeaker for road navigation, to buy a second mobile mount and have
one without and one with speaker. Exchange would be no problem between off-roading and on-roading, additional
cost AED approx. 150. Less than a separate marine mount and more handy.

User avatar
Rami Taha
Advanced
Advanced
Posts: 320
Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2012 4:08 pm
Location: Abu Dhabi

Post by Rami Taha »

Maybe just a recalibration will do. I had an issue with my garmin earlier and found that FM transmitter used to play flash memories was interfering.
Contacted garmin directly and they sent me the some files for calibration.

Sent from my GT-I9505

User avatar
Fox
Overseas Marshal
Overseas Marshal
Posts: 1162
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 9:00 am
Location: Abu Dhabi

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by Fox »

wolle wrote:
Fox wrote:I just want to share an experience. My Montana 650 is mounted with the original
Garmin windshield suction mount.
I realized that when I navigated to a certain co-ordinate using the compass page,
the compass swirls around without clear direction indication, as soon as I am
driving very slow or am stopped. This was very annoying.
After long brainstorming and various tests, I had the mount opened and the
internal loudspeaker removed. Thanks to AMIT ! VOILA ! The problem is solved !
So it was the magnetic field from the loudspeaker disturbing the Garmin magnetic
compass.
Now I do not have a voice any more when navigating on the road, but I have
clear direction in the desert. I keep the loudspeaker, it can be re-installed any
time.

Hallo Fox,

the crusial info in your post is " navigated to a certain co-ordinate using the compass page " so you are only using the layout of a compass but still navigating through GPS, so there is no influence of a magnetic field on that function. The nerves appearance stops when you are driving a few meters.

Regards


Wolfgang
Correct Wolle. Just sometimes I might not want to move a few meters , these could be just the wrong direction. :lol:
The 650 changes it's mode. When you move, it relies on the GPS. When you go slow or stop, it goes to magnetic operation.
By the way, I think in the menu you can switch this feature off and on.

User avatar
akhateeb
Posts: 684
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2012 9:00 am
Location: Dubai
Location: Discovery Gardens - Dubai

Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by akhateeb »

I tried it today with both the marine type & the suction cup mount, & both worked fine when moving & when standing still...

I updated my unit software a couple of weeks ago, so maybe they introduced some software solution for that?!
Every man dies ... Not every man REALLY lives!
Ayman 0508144630
_________________________
[*] 2014: Nissan Xterra 2014.. Stock except the front bumper..
[*] 2013-2014: Wrangler TJ, 3" Lift, Borla Catback, Roll Cage, Warn Bumpers & Winch, 2 ARB Lockers.. we're almost there!!
[*] 2012-2014: Infinity QX4, OME coils & Shocks around 20 mm additional height, 265x70x16 Cooper AT3 tires, custom pathy bumper, K&N filter ... !
[*] Audi A6 for the lovely wife...
Total Trips since Sep 2012 : 54 Trips
Last updated: 25-NOV-2013

User avatar
akhateeb
Posts: 684
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2012 9:00 am
Location: Dubai
Location: Discovery Gardens - Dubai

Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by akhateeb »

Btw, I liked the marine type more, although it had a permanent location in the TJ!

The suction cup mount keeps falling off from time to time especially if I forget it in the sun.. The marine type is a permanent solution..
Every man dies ... Not every man REALLY lives!
Ayman 0508144630
_________________________
[*] 2014: Nissan Xterra 2014.. Stock except the front bumper..
[*] 2013-2014: Wrangler TJ, 3" Lift, Borla Catback, Roll Cage, Warn Bumpers & Winch, 2 ARB Lockers.. we're almost there!!
[*] 2012-2014: Infinity QX4, OME coils & Shocks around 20 mm additional height, 265x70x16 Cooper AT3 tires, custom pathy bumper, K&N filter ... !
[*] Audi A6 for the lovely wife...
Total Trips since Sep 2012 : 54 Trips
Last updated: 25-NOV-2013

User avatar
Fox
Overseas Marshal
Overseas Marshal
Posts: 1162
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 9:00 am
Location: Abu Dhabi

Re: Garmin Montana 650 Magnetic Compass

Post by Fox »

MalteJK wrote:Maybe instead of totally removing the speaker ... lengthen the cables for them and put an external speaker, same speaker or aux cable on the other end - but just with enough distance ?
Agree Malte. I do not know what the impedance of the built-in speaker is. The remote speaker would have to match,
you would need to drill a hole into the mount for routing the wires to it. Or build a separate housing for the original
speaker instead of a new one. All this sounds a bit too much effort to me.

Post Reply