Page 2 of 3
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 3:09 am
by kerMitt
Nasser wrote:I drive a JK and will tell u how it drives on the sand. Stock, without mods, it does not perform as well as a TJ. After mods, it performs on the same level as a TJ.
Mind u the JK is heavy compared to the TJ. I did many modifications to my JK, and as Viking said, it does leave a big hole in your pocket. But man, my JK now performs same if not better than a TJ.
Now, suppose you opt for the TJ, u will use it for a limited period and when selling it, it will also leave a hole in your pocket
Go for the JK 8)
anTrax wrote:out of a score of 10, here is what i would grade both models after trying them
05/06 TJ
comfort: 3/10
Fuel Efficiency: 4/10
power VS weight ratio: 9/10
off road performance : 6/10 stock & 9/10 modified
off-road manoeuvrability: 9/10
off-road stability: 6/10 & 8/10 modified
safety: 6/10
maintenance cost: 5/10
re-sell value: 7/10
over-all grade: 6.1/10 stock & 6.7/10 modified
comfort: 6/10
Fuel Efficiency: 5/10
power VS weight ratio: 7/10
off road performance : 7/10 stock & 8/10 modified
off-road manoeuvrability: 8/10
off-road stability: 8/10 & 9/10 modified
safety: 7/10
maintenance cost: 4/10
re-sell value: 6/10
over-all grade: 6.4/10 stock & 6.7 modified
the above information is based on my own experience and feedback from other members
in summery:
TJ: the choice if you have another car for daily use
JK: the choice if you want to use the car for daily driving as well
as for the warranty, you can also find a TJ with the extended warranty package. any 05/06 TJ sold from western motors or trading enterprises has a warranty package from Chrysler in association with gulf warranties as long as the car has never missed a service in the dealer.
i hope the above information was useful
ok time for a tj driver to speak up
i have driven both in the desert the tj and the jk and in my personal opinion (No offence guys)
i own a 2005 tj and with little mods.
No jk (unless with a V8) can catch u on the stock engine..
to drive the jk in the desert u have to stay on low gear only... you cant drive on high.
jk's breaks aloot
jk's have alot of manufacturer defects alot stil unknown but the 1ns i know of are
1-bad A/C..it wil only cool while driving
2-4x4 cable
3-clutch wears out really fast
4-the fan makes a tik tik tik noise after along distance drive...
you aalso need to spend big buks for the jk to barley keep up with a stock tj with 31 tires... u owned a tj and u know how much fun it is to drive so if u can live with it on-road definatly go for a 2005-2006 tj
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:38 am
by Viking
I guess that was as scientific as it can be since it is, as Antrax says, based on judgement from several people and not true facts.
Good luck with your choice.
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 11:18 am
by Cybershot
anTrax wrote:out of a score of 10, here is what i would grade both models after trying them
05/06 TJ
comfort: 3/10
Fuel Efficiency: 4/10
power VS weight ratio: 9/10
off road performance : 6/10 stock & 9/10 modified
off-road manoeuvrability: 9/10
off-road stability: 6/10 & 8/10 modified
safety: 6/10
maintenance cost: 5/10
re-sell value: 7/10
over-all grade: 6.1/10 stock & 6.7/10 modified
comfort: 6/10
Fuel Efficiency: 5/10
power VS weight ratio: 7/10
off road performance : 7/10 stock & 8/10 modified
off-road manoeuvrability: 8/10
off-road stability: 8/10 & 9/10 modified
safety: 7/10
maintenance cost: 4/10
re-sell value: 6/10
over-all grade: 6.4/10 stock & 6.7 modified
the above information is based on my own experience and feedback from other members
in summery:
TJ: the choice if you have another car for daily use
JK: the choice if you want to use the car for daily driving as well
as for the warranty, you can also find a TJ with the extended warranty package. any 05/06 TJ sold from western motors or trading enterprises has a warranty package from Chrysler in association with gulf warranties as long as the car has never missed a service in the dealer.
i hope the above information was useful
Thank you Hani
That was the information I was looking for. Very detaild and well devided in categories.
I was looking for opinions and impressions, so this was very helpful!
Right now I believe both Jeeps are very close together and it might depent on the offer I get.
Due to my 40 km daily ( two ways ) traval to the office, I would say 60-40 for the JK.
Thanks
Tobias
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:26 pm
by mike0967
So, if its gonna be you daily beater to office and back, yeah, I would also say JK rather than TJ. You may also consider Auto gear over Manual. Traffic here has increased a lot during the last years and thus Auto tran would offer more comfort, too.
Mike
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:35 pm
by mike0967
anTrax wrote:mike0967 wrote: The JK is for people like me who need the comfort and
stay away from the extreme trips
Mike
:nono: looool
Hani, after what you have spend in time and money on your car I agree to your comment
But I guess you also know what I meant
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 1:37 pm
by mike0967
kerMitt wrote:
to drive the jk in the desert u have to stay on low gear only... you cant drive on high.
Sorry, but this is so wrong
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:18 pm
by halwa
Nasser wrote:I drive a JK and will tell u how it drives on the sand. Stock, without mods, it does not perform as well as a TJ. After mods, it performs on the same level as a TJ.
Mind u the JK is heavy compared to the TJ. I did many modifications to my JK, and as Viking said, it does leave a big hole in your pocket. But man, my JK now performs same if not better than a TJ.
Now, suppose you opt for the TJ, u will use it for a limited period and when selling it, it will also leave a hole in your pocket
Go for the JK 8)
Fully agree with you Nasser, a few mods here and there and you are good to go!!
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:24 pm
by halwa
mike0967 wrote:kerMitt wrote:
to drive the jk in the desert u have to stay on low gear only... you cant drive on high.
Sorry, but this is so wrong
Where dit you read/hear that 8O - dont agree with you at all !!
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2009 10:38 pm
by Nasser
halwa wrote:mike0967 wrote:kerMitt wrote:
to drive the jk in the desert u have to stay on low gear only... you cant drive on high.
Sorry, but this is so wrong
Where dit you read/hear that 8O - dont agree with you at all !!
The JK can be driven on Hi and it goes. However, I think Kermitt is talking about Extreme Advanced Trips, then yes, some of the routes take us to places where u find yourself compelled to use Low gears. I mix both, depending on the terrain. In Liwa, for example, there are places where u simply have to be in Low even if it is a TJ.
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Wed Jul 29, 2009 6:57 pm
by Cybershot
Just found this here
http://dubai.dubizzle.com/classified/au ... -wrangler/
Damned and I am not there. This would be mine!!
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 5:40 am
by YaYoS
TJ
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 10:56 am
by sherif78
Loks like Jeep science.
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Mon Aug 31, 2009 2:12 am
by MarwanJeeper
if like to keep ur car go for Jk,,have more options for modification encloding engines wich u can reach to 1000HP, Jk is more popular,
the problem is with the minivan engine (Stock engine) and its getting worse after lifting, so eventuallyyou have to go with Hemi engines(5.7,6.1,6.4,7.0,7.2) depends how much u wana spend...any way iam so happy with my JK.(its empty every poket)
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Wed Sep 23, 2009 8:08 pm
by Cybershot
Re: Advice needed! Jeep TJ or JK????
Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 1:30 am
by maddog
Good thread guys, enjoyed reading it.
Good luck in your search sony. err sorry cybershot
Ps you know there are both highly modded examples of both the TJ and JK for sale by club members on this site yes?